Saturday, November 21, 2026

CD/2LP Review: The Olivia Tremor Control - The Same Place


The Olivia Tremor Control
The Same Place

(Note: I usually don't use "the" in front of the band's name, but that's how their name appears on the spine.)

In person, the Olivia Tremor Control seemed like a band on the brink of coming apart at the seams. As the core of the band played some beautiful pop songs, all sorts of outré elements were spilling all over them. On one side of the stage, Bill Doss played guitar, sang and possessed the look of an aging teen idol, dressed up in a blazer that looked like something one might see on a lounge musician circa 1973. Or maybe the Raspberries would wear it. Or maybe the band that opened for them, hoping to be the next Raspberries.

Doss' partner in crime W. Cullen Hart ("Will") never stood in one place too long, unless he was singing into a microphone. Unlike Doss, he looked like he was wearing the same threads he wore while riding in the van earlier that day. Sometimes he stopped playing guitar mid-song and started banging on a tambourine. 

Behind them the three (or maybe it was four) piece horn section looked like some guys who might have sat behind me on the bleachers in gym class, hoping to just sit out the basketball game instead of being ignored on the court by the kids who took the game too seriously. These dudes might have looked nerdy but their horns helped to elevate the songs. Add a rhythm section, another guitar, bowed banjo and a reel-to-reel tape playing heaven-knows-what and looking like it would come unspooled at any moment, and the whole thing looked like some madcap musical club going awry. 

Except for one thing - nothing ever fell apart. The group, which numbered eight or nine when they reunited and came here to Pittsburgh back in 2011, worked like some unique machine, churning out real, modern teenage symphonies to God. 

It doesn't seem like that was 15 years ago, nor does it seem like 27 years ago that I first saw them here, on the campus of Carnegie Mellon, just a few months after I purchased their brilliant album Black Foliage: Animation Music Vol. 1. Both of these shows are still embedded in my brain. (Though a few details might be transposed from one show to the other.) 

But no sense denying that years that have passed. It's true. Doss passed away less than a year after that 2011 show following an aneurysm. He was 49. Hart, who suffered from multiple sclerosis (which might explain his guitar and tambourine action at the 2011 show), followed his friend in 2024. He was 52.

When the word got out that a new Olivia Tremor Control album was going to be released, it brought all kinds of questions. How is this possible? Who is responsible for it? And, most importantly, what's it like?

Producers Jason NeSmith (once of Casper & the Cookies, who once played here in town), Derek Almstead and Ron Kwasman took on what could be considered the massive task of completing, mixing and assembling The Same Place. Their efforts paid off because the final product not only fits perfectly in the Olivia Tremor Control canon but offers an even deeper look into the minds of Cullen and Doss.

Black Foliage included finely detailed notes about various musical passages from one song that were threaded into different songs throughout the album. Horn parts and rhythm instruments from the title track regularly popped up as interludes (or "animations," as the record called them) between proper songs. Ironically, the proper track was not one of the strongest tracks when it finally appeared on Side Three. 

The Same Place doesn't have those kinds of notes but it contains a lyric sheet and personnel listings for every track, two things that neither of the band's previous albums chronicled with such detail. This provides incredible insight to the music, making you listen for the 15-voice Golden Lanes Chorus on "It's Not Impossible for Golden Times." They show up in the song, in addition to an acoustic guitar, clarinet, bass, distorted Casio and three instruments played by Hart alone, all within 2:28. 

Maybe this reads too much into the lyrics, which could be audible on previous releases sporadically, but seeing them printed on the page, they almost come off like parting thoughts from the two singers to us listeners. This time, a recurring theme seems to wind through the album, encouraging listeners to take advice from nature on a path to follow, which eventually leads back to the same old place, "the world we left behind/ welcome, welcome home." 

The album's third side contains seven tracks that make up "The Path of the Parallels Suite," concluding with the title track (it jettisons "old" from the aforementioned track). By the end of side four, "Fossil Faun" finds Doss singing, "Oh little one/ don't ever leave here/ this is the place where you belong." The record ends with a locked groove of a percussive click, as if to emphasize not only the circle of life but that life will continue infinitely.

Or so it seems. 

Musically, the songs stand with the best of their work. "The Spinning Continues" begins with some musique concrète before diving into some driving garage rock, like a somnambulist version of S.F. Sorrow-era Pretty Things. Not until nearly half-way through the album does the band deliver a pure pop hit in "1/2 Way Down," but there is plenty of musical bliss leading up to that point. The "Parallels" suite stays more with the band's pop songs rather than their experimental side, like the 10-part "Green Typewriters" suite that appeared in the same place on Music from the Unrealized Film Script: Dusk at Cubist Castle. Incidentally, The Same Place has a cover layout very similar to the earlier album, though close examination shows it to be more of an homage. 

All the songs run together, making it all like some surreal dream, or an even better realization of the film script that the band thought they were creating on their debut full-length. Pressed on marbled vinyl, it's even harder to discern where one song ends and the next begins in a sea of tape effects. Overall, it almost seems like the band pulled off a narrative akin to The Little Prince or The Phantom Tollbooth, creating their own logic, and creating some killer hooks in the presentation.

Whether or not anyone wants to listen with lyric sheet, personnel and track listings in front of them or just get lost in the sound, The Same Place will turn people on easily. Bill and Will might not have been thinking of these songs as their parting words to fans, but it functions as such, in the best possible way. 

Thanks, guys. And thanks to Jason, Derek and Ron for bringing it to light. 



 



No comments: